Plot - pretty straightforward.

Characters - not a terrible amount of depth. Some get more time than others, which I didn't care for. There was a perfect balance of conversation and silence which I appreciated.

Setting - I loved the setting. It's dark which makes up for the lack of spooky. Plus holiday lights!

Puzzles - I love my math. Lots of numbers, and puzzles around every corner which I enjoy.

Sleuthing - Good bit of snooping and discovering new things. I needed help twice on "what to do next" but I am also impatient and on master level. This game was really fun to play as Nancy. I guessed the character right at the end!

I'd say a solid 8/10. Worth playing! (Yet, aren't they all?)